This week we revisit the lore of one mister Charles Manson. After examining new evidence*, we dare to ask questions like, did the CIA do the Manson murders? Was his posse test subjects to study LSD and manufactured psychosis? Is there a deeper ...

Whooosh! What was that? This week we whisk our listeners on a whirlwind tour of the atmosphere. Both here and up there, we talk air. Plus! Dylan faces death live on the podcast.

Avast ye! Welcome back to the liquid arc of this famous podcast. This week we dive into the mysterious depths of this blue marble with a tale of giant squid, unknown sounds, and missing feet.

I love the alien! * this episode was posted 25 days early for our patrons *

This week we welcome back our special Canadian guest Jeffrey for another installment of piping hot Pitches! Together we serve up a buffet of outside the box ideas and share a few belly-laughs along the way.Subscribe to Jeffrey's twitch c...

Y'all ready 2 hatch? 🐣 This week we compete for the title of Biggest Egg with three stories of sizable ovum. Sarah blows the lid off the egg basket of America, Dylan platforms Washington's claim to egg-fame, and Izzy unearths the eldes...

This week we respond to our most cherished listener's calls about werewolves, love, and mud. We also diagnose Dylan's illness, try to understand the rules of football, ponder the choices of IKEA, and fight over the definition of "passion." Has ...

BOO! Did that scare you? 👻 This week we bring to you a veritable who's boo of hauntings: Is a painting capable of evil? Can a

This week we let the public decide our three-letter topic and 33% of our listeners asked for a BIG episode! In this prodigious hour of colossal matters we discuss the largest...

This week we enter the liminal space between life and death to explore the nooks and crannies of an Indiana serial killer's home with the paranormal superstar himself Zak Bagans. That's right, we recorded a special recap of Ghost Adventures (s1...

Oink oink! In this perilous episode of the porcine pod, we peruse the pages of pig past. Did Shakira goad a pair of Spanish boars into attack? Is an assault rifle the solution to 30-50 feral porkers? Did Indiana serial killer Belle Guness feed ...

This week we are once again forced to set aside our differences and come to the red table to listen to your calls. You've given us an earful on sharks, punk music, illegal dumping, and a mysterious and inscrutable message. Finally, more mailbag...

SCHLORP! We mixed dirt and water together to make our topic: MUD. Whether brown or gray, we can count on one thing - it's wet! This week your hosts sling handfuls of mud lore. Black Sabbath refusing to play on a muddy island in Indiana, a big m...

Listen to the full episode on our Patreon!Welcome to another paywalled episode! This week the public...

Strap in, listener! It's time for another episode about a weird guy. This week the bimbos get into the life and legacy of Jack Parsons. Satanist, anti-capitalist, and self-taught rocket scientist. Did he get cucked by the inventor of Scientolog...

SPLOSH! This week we talk all things DUMPING. The fecal slurry of one 90's hitmaker; toxic chemicals in our drinking water that made us stupid; an alligator-guarded tire pile. We've got it all, baby!Want more DUMP?

Oh no, I feel sick... 😵̷̊̊̊̊̊ I ate 200 apple seeds, washed it down with Coca Cola, and now my hair is falling out. This week the bimbos gather to discuss toxicity, and not the male kind! We are talking poison: raw beans, sprouted potatoes and ...

In this late and hot episode, the 3 coworkers return to the mic for part 2 of Weird Indiana. In our last installment (E112) we spent the first hour explaining what Ind...

This week, your favorite mystery podcast boys tackle famous examples of Mass Psychogenic Illness- basically that's doctor language for "making things up for attention". Sarah accuses football players of faking CTE because they're tired, Izzy gi...

A preview of Episode 113: Grizzly Man, part of our ongoing Patreon movie club.  Listen to the full episode on our

Watch out coastal elites!! This episode is 100% HOOSIER. This week, Izzy mines Weird Indiana content from a book she bought at the airport while Dylan and Sarah undermine her at every turn by talking about Garfield.

This week, we are joined by world famous geologist and gemologist Laura, who gives us the 411 on the mysterious Eye of Richat and its possible (probable?) connection to the lost city of Atlantis. We discuss the theories of famous philosophers l...

A preview of Episode 110: Pitches 2! Listen to the full episode on our Patreon. 

This week, we welcome Sarah back from "maternity leave" with an all-out shark extravaganza! Dylan gives us the lowdown on drama in the YouTube shark influencer community, Sarah chronicles the feeding frenzy that followed the sinking of the USS ...

This week Dylan and Izzy take the helm for a second installment of the Maternity Leave Show! Join us for an unstructured power-hour of celebrating newborn life with fun games and friendship.